Piece of Cake – Happiest Cakes in Town

Sweet Treats for Your Sweetheart

Valentine’s Day treats are here

Shop Valentine’s Day

One Cookie Is Never Enough

Baked Fresh Daily

Order Cookies

Because Everyone Loves Baked Goods

Bakery gift cards available

Grab a Gift Card

Cupcakes That Steal the Show 🧁

Made fresh, frosted daily

Shop Cupcakes

Cakes Made to Celebrate 🎂

Birthdays, events & everyday celebrations

Order a Cake

People are talking

The staff was wonderful! What I felt like was a last minute request, was fulfilled and made the party perfect. Would give 10 stars if it was an option. Not only were the cakes beautiful, they were delicious!

The smell is amazing from the time you open the door to go in. Huge assortment of treats that you can walk in and buy. The cakes are gorgeous! Staff was very friendly and helpful!

Any idea you have they can make happen. These cakes were delicious and beautiful. I can’t recommend them enough and am happy I have a place to go to from now on out!

From my wedding cake to baby shower to birthdays I have always been blown away. This is the first bakery I have ordered from and I wont go anywhere else. Their cheesecake is amazing! The cakes are light with a balanced flavor and the icing is perfect and not overly sweet so you can enjoy the flavor the cake.

We went downtown for a walk down mainland stumbled across this shop. What drew us in was the pupcakes and bones. I like to bring home treats for my dog so I feel less guilty about leaving him 😆 They were out of pupcakes and quickly whipped one up for him. I brought it home and he ate it so quick!

About Us

Piece of Cake Bakery was founded in 1998 by two sisters that had a passion for baking and an artistic flare. Cate and Kristi wanted to share their family recipes with their hometown. Over the years, their menu has expanded to add new recipes to the old favorites. Now, 25 years later, Piece of Cake is the premier bakery in Evansville.