September is our Birthday!

Celebrate with $28 Grab & Go Cakes!

Bringing the party to your table all month long.

👇 See our daily specials below! 👇

Cakes Made to Celebrate

Birthdays, Events, & Everyday Celebrations!

One Cookie is Never Enough

Baked Fresh Daily!

Cupcakes that Steal the Show

Made Frssh, Frosted Daily

Because Everyone Loves Baked Goods

Bakery Gift Cards Available

All September

Buy one Get one for 28¢

We are so incredibly grateful to have been your neighborhood bakery for the past 28 years. To say a huge thank you for a generation of smiles, stories, and shared treats, we are celebrating all month long with a special gift to our community. Every single day, we are featuring a different daily favorite as a Buy One, Get One for just 28 cents special. Check out our daily calendar below to find your favorites, grab a friend, and come celebrate this milestone with us.

Monday

Iced Butter Cookie

Tuesday

Slice of Cake of the Day

Wednesday

Signature Cookie

Thursday

Jumbo Cupcake

Friday

Pie Day Friday - Slice of cake

Saturday

28¢ Cup of coffee with the purchase of a Cinnamon Roll

Daily Giveaways

Don’t forget to swing by and see us during the week! We’re also hosting fun daily giveaways right here in the shop. It’s our favorite way to say thank you in person, so come on in and see what surprise is waiting for you today!

People are talking

The staff was wonderful! What I felt like was a last minute request, was fulfilled and made the party perfect. Would give 10 stars if it was an option. Not only were the cakes beautiful, they were delicious!
E Fox
The smell is amazing from the time you open the door to go in. Huge assortment of treats that you can walk in and buy. The cakes are gorgeous! Staff was very friendly and helpful!
Stephany Cowe
Any idea you have they can make happen. These cakes were delicious and beautiful. I can’t recommend them enough and am happy I have a place to go to from now on out!
Michelle Stucky Niehaus
From my wedding cake to baby shower to birthdays I have always been blown away. This is the first bakery I have ordered from and I wont go anywhere else. Their cheesecake is amazing! The cakes are light with a balanced flavor and the icing is perfect and not overly sweet so you can enjoy the flavor the cake.
Bre Bayer
We went downtown for a walk down mainland stumbled across this shop. What drew us in was the pupcakes and bones. I like to bring home treats for my dog so I feel less guilty about leaving him 😆 They were out of pupcakes and quickly whipped one up for him. I brought it home and he ate it so quick!
Anna

About Us

Piece of Cake Bakery was founded in 1998 by two sisters that had a passion for baking and an artistic flare. Cate and Kristi wanted to share their family recipes with their hometown. Over the years, their menu has expanded to add new recipes to the old favorites. Now, 25 years later, Piece of Cake is the premier bakery in Evansville. 

Order Your
Cake Today

Check out our online shop. Where placing your order is a Piece of Cake! 72 hours notice

Order Now

Our Services

We have cakes, cookie,  party trays, gift baskets, and other treats to make all your occasions just a little bit sweeter.

  • Parties
  • Weddings
  • Corporate Events
  • Gluten Free Options

Cakes

We have cakes for all occasions... birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, and more.

72 Hours Notice

Order Here

Cupcakes

Looking for something sweet… just smaller? Be sure to check out our cupcakes.

72 Hours Notice

Order Here

Pies

Do you have apple pie in the sky hopes or any other flavor? Have a look at all our amazing flavors.

72 Hours Notice

Order Here

Weddings

Nothing makes us happier than to help bring your wedding cake vision to life. Let us know what you two have planned.

More Info

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
Name*
Max. file size: 100 MB.

Contact Information

Facebook Twitter Instagram

Celebrating the 812! 🧁

Grab-and-go cupcakes for exactly $8.12

Stop in 10am to 2pm

This wednesday only Aug 12!
(812 see what we did there)

Celebrating our friends, family, & neighbors

Take 5% OFF your online order with code PRIDE

Chocolate-Covered Strawberry Season 🍓

💝 Save $5 on a dozen
📅 Order by Feb 12
📍 Pickup Feb 13 or 14

Pre-Order & Save
Click here

Looking for the finishing touches for Christmas dinner or a last minute gift?

Look Here
Valentine's Day Extended Hours

Enjoy our extended hours this Valentine’s Day for your convenience!

We will be open from 9-5 for pick ups.

Piece of Cake Bakery will be closed from Dec. 25th until Jan 5nd.  Order pick ups will resume on Jan 6th.