People are talking

About Us

Piece of Cake Bakery was founded in 1998 by two sisters that had a passion for baking and an artistic flare. Cate and Kristi wanted to share their family recipes with their hometown. Over the years, their menu has expanded to add new recipes to the old favorites. Now, 25 years later, Piece of Cake is the premier bakery in Evansville. 

Order Your
Cake Today

Check out our online shop. Where placing your order is a Piece of Cake! 72 hours notice

Our Services

We have cakes, cookie,  party trays, gift baskets, and other treats to make all your occasions just a little bit sweeter.


We have cakes for all occasions... birthdays, anniversaries, holidays, and more.

72 Hours Notice


Looking for something sweet… just smaller? Be sure to check out our cupcakes.

72 Hours Notice


Do you have apple pie in the sky hopes or any other flavor? Have a look at all our amazing flavors.

72 Hours Notice


Nothing makes us happier than to help bring your wedding cake vision to life. Let us know what you two have planned.

Contact Us

"*" indicates required fields

Max. file size: 100 MB.
This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.

Contact Information

Valentine's Day Extended Hours

Enjoy our extended hours this Valentine’s Day for your convenience!

We will be open from 9-5 for pick ups.